top of page

Independent Review Panels in Schools and what the Lift Schools Judgement Means

Writer: Wendy Kravetz
Wendy Kravetz
1 day ago
3 min read

Permanent exclusion has lasting consequences for a child and their family. It also

places significant responsibilities on headteachers, governing boards and those

arranging an independent review.


Understanding the different roles matters. The governing board decides whether to

reinstate the pupil. An Independent Review Panel reviews the board’s decision not to

reinstate.


This article reflects the DfE statutory guidance effective from 26 July 2026 and the

subsequent judgement in R (HVF) v Lift Schools [2026] EWHC 2088 (Admin).


What is an Independent Review Panel?


An Independent Review Panel, or IRP, reviews a governing board’s decision not to

reinstate a permanently excluded pupil, applying judicial review principles.

It can:


  • uphold the governing board’s decision;

  • recommend that the governing board reconsider reinstatement; or

  • quash the decision and direct the governing board to reconsider reinstatement.


An IRP cannot order reinstatement. That decision remains with the governing

board.


Who arranges the review?


The local authority is responsible for maintained schools and pupil referral units; the

academy trust is responsible for academies. This can be delegated to London


Parents normally have 15 school days from notification of the governing board’s

decision to apply. The review must begin within 15 school days of the application,

although it can be adjourned.


Panels have three or five members, representing the lay chair, governor and

headteacher categories. Members must meet eligibility, independence and training

requirements.


What about special educational needs and disability?


Parents can request an independent SEN expert with their application, whether or

not the school recognises their child as having SEN. There is no charge to the family.


The panel must seek and consider the expert’s advice. It must also meet its own

equality duties, including making reasonable adjustments to support participation.


What did the Lift Schools judgement clarify?


The High Court quashed the decision challenged in Lift Schools and explained the

scrutiny required when a governing board decides not to reinstate a pupil.


The board must make its own assessment, based on the circumstances at the time

of its hearing. It must consider both the behaviour policy breach and whether the

pupil’s continued attendance would cause serious harm to their education or welfare,

or that of others.


It must also assess proportionality. This means considering the likely harm if the

pupil returns, the likelihood of that harm, the impact of permanent exclusion on the

pupil, and whether less restrictive measures could adequately address the risk.


Simply describing the incident and stating that exclusion was proportionate does not

explain that assessment. The reasons must show how the board reached its

decision, taking account of the pupil’s circumstances, including SEND.


What does Lift mean for an IRP?


The judgment makes clear that an IRP must scrutinise the governing board’s

reasoning. It should not allow substantial gaps in the original reasons to be repaired

through new explanations at the review.


Inadequate reasons will generally require quashing where they fail to demonstrate a

proper approach, subject to the exceptions identified by the court. The judgment also

distinguishes deciding whether to quash from considering whether to recommend

reconsideration, when later evidence may be relevant.



What happens after the review?


The parties must receive the panel’s written decision and reasons without delay.


Where reconsideration is recommended or directed, the governing board must

reconsider reinstatement within ten school days of receiving notice. It must address

the IRP’s findings and explain its reconsidered decision.


Practical IRP support and online training


At London Governance, we chair IRPs, serve as lay members and provide specialist

clerking. We understand the preparation involved before, during and after a hearing.


We support schools, academy trusts and local authorities across England, whether

they need a fully coordinated review, individual panel members or an experienced

IRP clerk.


Our online IRP training course launches in early December 2026 and will be

available 24/7. Written by the Directors of London Governance and informed by our practical experience, it covers preparation, the hearing and what follows, with

reference to the July 2026 guidance and relevant case law.



For help arranging a review, explore our IRP services or email hello@ldngov.co.uk.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page