top of page

What Is a School Governance Review? A Guide for Boards and Trusts

Writer: Wendy Kravetz
Wendy Kravetz
Jan 27, 2024
4 min read

Updated: Nov 12

The Power of School Governance Reviews


A school governance review is an independent assessment of how well a governing board or trust board is working. Embarking on one is a strategic move: it gives a meticulous examination of compliance and governance structures, and ends with practical recommendations. This guide explains why reviews matter, when to commission one, what happens during the process and how to make the most of it.


Key takeaways

  • A review examines compliance and governance structures, and shows where a board can improve.

  • An external reviewer brings independence and expertise, while still reflecting internal views.

  • Timing matters: use the findings to inform budgeting, strategy and recruitment.

  • Reviews work best as part of continuous improvement, with outcomes shared openly.


What is a school governance review?


A governance review is an external assessment of how effectively a board operates. The reviewer looks at how the board is structured, how it makes decisions, how well it supports and challenges school leaders, and whether it meets its statutory and regulatory responsibilities. A good review is not a tick-box exercise. It shows what is working, where the board could develop and what to do next.


Why does governance matter?


Ensuring continual compliance with laws and regulations is paramount. A robust governance review helps build a culture where the board’s work is aligned with the school’s purpose, and it gives you a recognised framework for structured, best-practice assessment. The government publishes an official guide to arranging an effective external review of governance for schools and academy trusts in England, which you can read on GOV.UK. For trusts, reviews should explore governance across the whole trust, not only at board level. The DfE’s Academy Trust Handbook sets out the wider expectations on trust boards.


When should a board commission a review?


Timing is key. Plan a review strategically, and use what it finds to inform budgeting, strategy and recruitment decisions. Regular reviews are recommended as good practice, but there is no specific requirement for maintained schools. Common triggers include:


  • A new chair, headteacher, CEO or clerk to governors

  • A school joining a trust, or a trust growing

  • Preparing for an inspection, or responding to feedback about leadership and governance

  • A feeling that meetings are not giving enough challenge

  • Difficulties with board relationships, attendance or recruitment



What does a governance review look at?


The scope reflects your board’s priorities and can include:


  • Board structure, roles and committee effectiveness

  • Governance documents, including the scheme of delegation and terms of reference

  • Strategic leadership, challenge and accountability

  • Observation of board and committee meetings

  • Interviews with governors, trustees and senior leaders

  • Compliance with relevant statutory and regulatory requirements

  • Comparison with recognised good practice, such as guidance from the National Governance Association


Who can carry out a governance review?


There are various routes, from trustee support to external consultancy. External consultants offer independence and expertise, and can give a holistic view that still takes account of internal perspectives. It helps when the reviewer has done the job: London Governance’s directors are current Chairs of Governors, and we work regularly with more than 20 schools and trusts. You can meet the team on our about page.


What should you consider before a review?


  1. Framework matters. Adopt a standard framework that fits your school’s context.

  2. External insight. Use an independent reviewer for unbiased facilitation, alongside thorough internal input.

  3. Inclusive gathering. Ask for views from trustees and senior managers, and consider wider consultation with staff, parents, pupils and members.


What happens during a governance review?


Most reviews follow five stages:


  1. Agree the scope. The reviewer discusses your priorities and desired outcomes.

  2. Review the documents. Policies, minutes, terms of reference and the scheme of delegation are compared against good practice.

  3. Observe meetings. The reviewer sees how discussion, challenge and decisions work in practice.

  4. Hold interviews. Governors, trustees and senior leaders give their views in confidence.

  5. Report and feedback. Findings are written up and shared with the board.


What will you receive at the end?


You will receive a written report summarising the findings, identifying strengths and making practical recommendations, so the board can see where it is performing well and where targeted changes would help most.


How do skills and diversity audits fit in?


Regular skills and diversity audits, alongside governance reviews, give a comprehensive picture of where the board can develop. Gaps can then be addressed through recruitment, training or increased awareness. Our governor and trustee training can help close the gaps a review identifies.



Should you share the findings?


Yes, openness builds confidence. Share an overview of the findings and the commitments that follow, and show accountability for the changes you make. This reassures stakeholders that the board is serious about good governance. Take care with sensitive information when communicating.


How do you keep improving after a review?


Committing to continual reviews shows a dedication to meaningful change. Embed that commitment in your annual trustees’ report to show progress and the areas you are focusing on for governance development.


FAQs


Is a governance review the same as an inspection?

No. A governance review is commissioned by the board to support its own improvement. It is not an inspection and does not replace one.


How often should a board review its governance?

Many boards review periodically, and many also do so after a significant change such as a new chair or joining a trust. Regular reviews are good practice rather than a requirement for maintained schools.


Who is involved in a governance review?

Usually the chair, the clerk, governors or trustees, and the headteacher or CEO, through documents, meetings and interviews.


What should a board do after receiving the report?

Agree an action plan, give each recommendation an owner and deadline, and review progress at future meetings.


How London Governance can help


We do not believe in a one-size-fits-all review. Our independent governance reviews are built around your priorities, with the scope agreed in advance and a written report your board can act on. Our governance services for schools support boards across London and the wider UK. If your board would like to explore a review, get in touch with our team.



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page